Starting with applications filed on or after September 18, the way the Affidavit of Support is weighed has changed

Something has changed recently in our family-based green card consultations and cases. Even when the sponsoring relative or a joint sponsor submits an Affidavit of Support (Form I-864, a promise to be responsible for the applicant's living expenses) that comfortably exceeds the income requirement, USCIS is increasingly requesting more documents or denying the application because of the applicant's own financial situation. What USCIS examines is "public charge," that is, whether the applicant is likely to depend on government assistance in the future. On top of that, a new rule that took effect on September 18 reduced the weight the Affidavit of Support carries in the review for applications filed on or after that date.

The Affidavit of Support Was Always a Requirement, Never a Guarantee

"Immigration law requires that, in deciding public charge, at least the applicant's age, health, family status, assets and financial status, and education and skills be considered, and says the Affidavit of Support 'may' also be considered."

Most family-based green card applicants must submit an Affidavit of Support. If the sponsoring relative's income and assets fall below 125% of the poverty-line income the government sets for each household size, the requirement can be met by adding the income of family members living with the sponsor, or by having a joint sponsor submit a separate Affidavit of Support. If there is no Affidavit of Support or it falls short of the requirement, that alone is a ground for a public charge denial, before any other circumstances are weighed.

Even so, an Affidavit of Support above the requirement has never guaranteed a green card. For example, suppose a relative with ample income stepped in as a joint sponsor because the U.S. citizen husband's income was not enough. If the wife applying for the green card has never worked and has no skills to point to, then among the factors the law says to consider, work and skills count against her. The 2022 regulation stated that a sufficient Affidavit of Support would be considered favorably, and in practice it was widely assumed that the public charge issue would usually pass as long as the Affidavit of Support was strong.

The September 18 Rule Removed the Favorable-Consideration Provision

"In explaining the new rule, the Department of Homeland Security stated that, depending on the facts of the case, an officer may not consider the Affidavit of Support at all."

The new rule, published on July 20 in the Federal Register, the government's official journal, and effective September 18, eliminated the public charge provisions of the 2022 regulation. The explanation accompanying the rule states that any fact relevant to the applicant's self-sufficiency is part of the review. The burden of showing that there is no public charge concern is also on the applicant.

The rule applies to green card applications (Form I-485) postmarked on or after September 18, or filed online on or after that date. Because the framework of looking at age, health, family status, assets, and education and skills was the same before, an application filed earlier can also run into trouble if the applicant's own situation is very weak.

The USCIS Policy Manual, the agency's internal adjudication guidance, says officers should generally consider a sufficient Affidavit of Support. With a supervisor's agreement, however, an officer may decline to consider it. In that case, the officer must state the reason in the Notice of Intent to Deny sent before a denial, or in the denial notice. Even when it is considered, how much it counts depends on how likely the sponsor is to actually provide support.

The guidance looks at the sponsor's relationship to the applicant and whether they live together, whether the sponsor actually supported people they sponsored in the past, and how far the sponsor's income and assets exceed the requirement. It also looks at whether the sponsor receives government benefits, whether the sponsor has ever had a USCIS fee waived, and records such as bankruptcy. If a distant acquaintance living elsewhere has sponsored several people on income barely above the requirement, that Affidavit of Support may be given less weight.

The State Department guidance used when immigrant visas are issued abroad (September 2024 version) generally treats a properly submitted Affidavit of Support as sufficient.

Now the Applicant's Own Situation Is at the Center of the Review

"The Policy Manual explains that for applicants who are retired, near retirement, or have no plans to work, retirement plans, pensions, and household assets become more important."

The new green card application asks applicants to pick ranges for their household's annual income, assets, and debts, and to include even credit card balances in debts. It asks them to list their skills and certifications, and if they have ever received government benefits available only to people with low income, it asks when and for what reason.

Here, the applicant's situation means the household's situation, not the applicant's alone. The guidance treats as one household the family members living with the applicant (a spouse, parents, and unmarried children and siblings under 21), plus anyone who claims the applicant, or whom the applicant claims, as a dependent on a tax return, and looks at their income and assets together. The income of a U.S. citizen spouse living with the applicant is also counted toward the applicant's household income.

Applicants of particular concern are elderly parents with no income or assets who will rely on a U.S. citizen child, people with no work history and no plans to work, and people with a serious illness and no health insurance. For applicants covered by the new rule, benefits they themselves received on or after September 18, such as Medicaid (health coverage for people with low income) or food stamps (food assistance), are also part of the review. Benefits received by family members living with the applicant are, as a rule, not counted as the applicant's own.

On health, USCIS generally follows what the doctor wrote on the medical examination form (Form I-693). If it lists a condition that could interfere with working or living independently, the applicant must show health insurance that can cover treatment costs, along with household income.

Many spouses applying for a green card through marriage have no U.S. work history because they do not yet have work authorization. They must not work without authorization to build a record. Work experience and certifications from their home country, and a job offer letter stating that they will be hired once they receive work authorization, are evidence that they will be able to work in the future.

The guidance also lists evidence that helps: work history and plans for future employment, degrees, licenses, and certifications, skills including English ability, health insurance that is not a benefit available only to people with low income, and savings and assets. The form instructions generally do not require public charge evidence other than the Affidavit of Support and its supporting documents. However, the Department of Homeland Security wrote in its explanation of the rule that applicants should submit evidence of self-sufficiency if they have it, and USCIS is not required to send a Request for Evidence before deciding. It is safer to submit it with the initial application.

If You Receive a Request for Evidence or a Denial Notice

"Immigration regulations provide that there is no appeal from a USCIS decision denying a green card application."

If you receive a Request for Evidence or a Notice of Intent to Deny based on public charge, your response must strengthen both the Affidavit of Support and the applicant's household situation, addressing the points the notice raised.

If the sponsor's relationship to the applicant or the sponsor's other sponsorships were flagged, you may also consider having a family member closer to the applicant submit a new Affidavit of Support as a joint sponsor. A joint sponsor must be a U.S. citizen or permanent resident, age 18 or older and living in the United States, who meets the requirement with income or assets.

The reason for a denial may also be discretion rather than public charge. Discretion means that even if the applicant is eligible, USCIS can weigh the circumstances and decline to approve. In a May 21 memo, USCIS emphasized this point again and reaffirmed that when it denies as a matter of discretion, it must weigh the favorable and unfavorable factors and set them out in the notice. Among discretionary denial notices we have seen in practice, one cited the applicant's overstay together with a lack of work experience as unfavorable factors.

There is no appeal, but within 30 days of the denial (33 days if the decision was received by mail), you can file a motion asking USCIS to reconsider or reopen the decision. An applicant with no other immigration status may be placed in immigration court proceedings after a denial, and then the green card application is argued again before an immigration judge rather than USCIS. If you are not placed in proceedings and are still eligible to apply for a green card inside the United States, you can strengthen your situation and file a new application with USCIS.

If public charge is the only problem and every other requirement is met, there is also a way to receive a green card by posting a bond in an amount set by USCIS. The applicant cannot request this on their own; it is available only when USCIS offers it in a Notice of Intent to Deny.

Several states including New York, New York City, and nonprofit organizations have sued over the new rule in federal court in New York. So far, however, no order has stopped the rule. The schedule for the parties' written arguments runs through March 12 next year, and no date has been set for a decision. For now, prepare on the assumption that cases will be reviewed under the current rule.

Conclusion

The Affidavit of Support is now a document that is necessary but not enough on its own. First, gather the work history, job offers, certifications, health insurance, and savings records of the applicant and the household, and submit them with the initial application. Second, when choosing a sponsor, do not look only at income. A close family member who lives with the applicant is better, and so is income well above the requirement. Third, if you receive a notice based on public charge or discretion, check the response deadline first and answer by strengthening the points raised. If you applied before September 18 and are waiting for a decision, prepare the same documents.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. If my Affidavit of Support (Form I-864) comfortably exceeds the income requirement, will I pass the public charge review?

Not necessarily. Immigration law requires that at least the applicant's age, health, family status, assets and financial status, and education and skills be considered, and says the Affidavit of Support may also be considered. Having no Affidavit of Support, or one below the requirement, is by itself a ground for denial, but exceeding the requirement does not guarantee a green card. The new rule that took effect September 18 eliminated the 2022 provision that a sufficient Affidavit of Support would be considered favorably, and an officer may decline to consider the Affidavit of Support with a supervisor's agreement.

Q. Which green card applications does the September 18 public charge rule apply to?

It applies to green card applications (Form I-485) postmarked on or after September 18, or filed online on or after that date. Applications filed earlier were also reviewed under the same framework of age, health, family status, assets, and education and skills, so they can run into trouble if the applicant's own situation is very weak.

Q. What can I do if my green card is denied on public charge grounds?

There is no appeal from a USCIS green card denial. Within 30 days of the denial (33 days if the decision was received by mail), you can file a motion asking USCIS to reconsider or reopen. An applicant with no other immigration status may be placed in immigration court proceedings, and then the green card application is argued again before an immigration judge. If public charge is the only problem and every other requirement is met, there is also a way to receive a green card by posting a bond when USCIS offers it in a Notice of Intent to Deny.

Disclaimer: This column provides general information and is not legal advice for a particular case. Individual immigration matters should be discussed with a qualified immigration attorney.

Law Office of Jin D. Cho, P.C.

NEW YORK OFFICE (Flushing) 35-24 154th Street, Flushing, NY 11354

(T) 718-353-2699 (F) 718-353-8132

NEW JERSEY OFFICE 560 Sylvan Avenue, 3Fl., Englewood Cliffs, NJ 07632

(T) 201-449-0009

choattorneys.com | Marriage green card online: greencard4spouse.com